Tune the App, Not the SQL – DBA Sherlock’s Adventures in Hibernate/jOOQ Land

Last weekend at Trivadis Tech Event, in addition to my session on Oracle 12c Client High Availability for Java (Application Continuity, Transaction Guard … choose your degrees of freedom”), I gave a quite different talk called Tune the App, Not the SQL – DBA Sherlock’s Adventures in Hibernate/jOOQ Land”.

In a nutshell, what is it all about? Well, if you’re a DBA, you might sometimes (or often, or seldom – depends on your job ;-)) do what we call “SQL Tuning”. It might look like this: You get a call that the application “is slow”. Fortunately, you’re able to narrow that down quickly, and it’s just “the click on that button” that is slow. Fortunately, too, the application is well instrumented, and getting traces for specific tasks is not a problem. So you get a SQL trace file, run tkprof on it, and obtain the problematic SQLs in order of elapsed time. Then you analyse the “Top SQL”. You may find it should be rewritten, or that it would benefit from an index. Perhaps adding additional data structures might help, such as creating a materialized view. Perhaps you’re unlucky and just an ugly hint will fix it.

So you tell the developers “please rewrite that, like this”, or you create that index. And after, it’s waiting and hoping that performance will improve – noticeably, that is. Because tuning that single statement might – if you’re unlucky – not make that much of a difference.

There is, however, another approach to tuning application performance (always talking about the DB related part of it here, of course), and that has to do with the application logic and not single statements. There is an excellent demonstration of this in Stéphane Faroults very recommendable book “Refactoring SQL applications”, in fact, this is right at the beginning of the book and something that immediately “draws you in” (it was like that for me :-)).

Application logic affects what, when, and how much data is fetched. Of course, there are many aspects to this – for example, it just may not be possible to replace two DB calls by one simply because another service has to be queried in between. Also, there will have to be a tradeoff between performance and readability/maintainability of the code. But often there will be a choice. And you will see in the presentation it is not always that combining two queries into one results in better performance.

In fact, it all depends. So the first conclusion is the ubiquitous “don’t just assume, but test”.

There is another aspect to this, though. While Stéphane Faroult, in his test case, uses plain JDBC, I am using – and comparing, in a way – two commonly used frameworks: Hibernate and jOOQ. (For an “interdisciplinary introduction” to Hibernate, see my talk from previous Tech Event, Object Relational Mapping Tools – let’s talk to each other!. Quite a contrast, jOOQ is a lightweight, elegant wrapper framework providing type safety and near-100% control over the generated SQL.)

Now while for a DBA looking at a raw trace file, it will always be a challenge to “reverse engineer” application logic from the SQL sent to the database (even if plain JDBC or jOOQ are being used), the difficulties rise to a new dimension with Hibernate :-). In the talk, I am showing a DBA – who doesn’t need to be convinced any more about the importance of application logic – trying to make sense of the flow of statements in a trace file: the only information he’s got. And it turns out to be very difficult …

But as he’s not just “some DBA”, but Sherlock, he of course has his informants and doesn’t remain stuck with his DB-only view of the world – which brings me to one of my ceterum censeo’s, which is “DBAs and developers, let’s talk to each other” :-).

The slides are here.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s